Wine Lists

Sample our award-winning Wine List with a range of local, Australian and international varieties. Offering wines by the glass or bottle, from an extensive wine list featuring over 600 wines, affectionately known as the Bible, ask to see it at the bar.

“Settlers list has become legendary…..

It’s a must-visit place to eat and drink for a wine lover visiting Margaret River. Settlers showcases the local wines, especially the newest and best, within a context of the world of wine. Lillian, La Kooki and Swinney sit alongside William Downie, Wendouree and Yarra Yering; or Cuilleron, Pio Cesare, and Williams Selyem. The list itself is wonderfully chaotic, crammed with information and (informed) opinion, offering great bottles at prices even winewriters can afford.”  

Gourmet Traveller Wine Nov 2021

We offer over 30 wines by the glass, and 600 by the bottle, with a great range of local, international and zero alcohol wines available. We use enomatic and coravin wine preservation systems, allowing us to offer rare and limited wines by the glass.

Margaret River and West Australia – We have loads of wines from our region, with a separate page for our own regional classics, chardonnay and cabernet, a special WA Pinot Nior page from our neighbours further south. We also have a wide range from other Australian regions focusing on interesting small family wineries.

Rare and limited wines – Wines we have ben collecting over the years, as well as wines that are highly allocated or awarded wines with only few available.

International wines – We love Italian wines and have built up a great selection of wines from Piedmont (Nebbiolo) and Tuscany (Sangiovese). As well as New Zealand, North America: California, Oregon. South America: Chile, Germany, Austria, France, Spain, Morocco, Mexico.

Natural Wines – Bio-dynamic, organic/sustainable, un-sulphured and vegan wines available.

Accolades for our wine list

2022 BEST COUNTRY RESTAURANT WINE LIST – Wine List of the Year Awards.

2022 STAR WINE LIST AWARDS Gold Star Winner – Sustainable Wine List

2021  GOURMET TRAVELLER WINE  Wine List of the Year Awards: WA’S BEST WINE LIST AWARD and AUSTRALIA’S BEST LISTING OF A REGIONS WINES
2009-2021 Hall of Fame 3 wine glasses
2019, 2018 & 2017 Hall of Fame Best Listing of WA Wines
2009-2021 Hall of Fame “Best Pub Restaurant Wine List National Award”
2019 Best Wine List WA 

Oct 2021 WINESLINGER TOP 50 VENUE as voted by Young Guns of Wine, Wine Industry & Winemakers ONE OF THE TOP 100 PLACES FOR WINE FUN”
Young Gun of Wine Australia:  WINESLINGER TOP 50 Venue 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018    &  2019 National Peoples’ Choice’ Award

July 2021 WINE SPECTATOR 2020 Restaurant Wine List of the Year Awards…
2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015 Awarded 2 wine glasses – Award of Excellence – Worlds Best Wine Lists
Best of Award of Excellence  “Restaurants that are destinations for serious wine lovers, showing a deep commitment to wine.
Wine lists that display excellent breadth across multiple wine-growing regions and/or significant vertical depth of top producers.”

July 2020 WINE SPECTATOR Restaurant Wine List of the Year Awards

2020, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015 Awarded 2 wine glasses – Award of Excellence – Worlds Best Wine Lists

Nov 2019 AHA-WA AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE Best Wine List of the year
2019 2018 2017 Hall of Fame

2019 and 2020 WINESLINGER TOP 50 VENUES as voted by Young Guns of Wine, Wine Industry & Winemakers

‘Top 50 Places to Drink Wine in Australia’ National “Peoples Choice” award.

July 2019 GOURMET TRAVELLER WINE 2019 Wine List of the Year Awards
2019 Best Wine List WA
2019, 2018 & 2017 Best Listing of WA Wines
2009-2019 Hall of Fame “Best Pub Restaurant Wine List National Award”